Icahn Issues Open Letter to Shareholders of Mentor Graphics

NEW YORK, April 21, 2011 — (PRNewswire) —

Carl C. Icahn today issued the following open letter to shareholders of Mentor Graphics Corporation:

Dear Fellow Shareholders:

It is time for a change on the Board of Directors of Mentor Graphics. For the first time, shareholders of Mentor Graphics are being presented with an opportunity to elect directors not nominated by the entrenched Board. Eight years have passed without a single director joining or leaving. All three of the directors we seek to replace have been on the Board since 1994, just after Walden Rhines became CEO. One of the directors we seek to replace is actually the lead independent director, despite spending over 17 years on the Board with the CEO and the President. Mentor's stock is now at approximately the same level as it was in 1994 while CEO Walden Rhines received $65 million in compensation.(i) This Board has failed to hold management accountable to shareholders in our opinion. Shareholders can send a strong signal to this entrenched Board by electing our three nominees.

Our plan is not limited to a sale of the Company. We have a clear plan to improve earnings per share through improved oversight in two key areas where over the past 17 years this Board has allowed for a bloated expense structure and massive share dilution:

(1) SG&A growth in excess of Total Revenue growth; and (2) Dilution.

Since 1994, Mentor's annualized revenue growth was 5.3% while its annualized SG&A growth was 5.7%. This has led SG&A as a percentage of Total Revenues to increase to 46%. This is quite unfortunate for shareholders, as with 5.3% annualized revenue growth it seems absurd to us that Mentor could not better leverage its SG&A expenses.



FY 1994

FY 2011

Total Revenues

$390MM

$915MM




Marketing and Selling

$129MM

$321MM

General and Administration

$40MM

$100MM

Total SG&A Expenses

$169MM

$421MM




Annualized Revenue Growth


5.3%

Annualized SG&A Growth


5.7%

SG&A % of Total Revenues

43%

46%




Even today, Mentor's SG&A as a percentage of Revenues is significantly higher than its closest peers. We believe that Cadence's ratio of SG&A as a percentage of Revenues would be lower if it was not still undergoing the effects of a transition from a term based model to a ratable model that temporarily lowers revenues. Even Magma Design Automation, a competitor of Mentor Graphics with just $135M of Revenues, has roughly the same ratio of SG&A as a percentage of Revenues.


LTM(ii)

Mentor

Synopsys

Cadence

Total Revenues

$915MM

$1,415MM

$936MM

SG&A

$421MM

$458MM

$392MM

SG&A as a % of Revenues

46.0%

32.4%

41.9%





1 | 2 | 3 | 4  Next Page »



Review Article Be the first to review this article
Featured Video
Editorial
Peggy AycinenaWhat Would Joe Do?
by Peggy Aycinena
Qualcomm’s Lu Dai: Energetic leadership for Accellera
More Editorial  
Jobs
Sr. Staff Design SSD ASIC Engineer for Toshiba America Electronic Components. Inc. at San Jose, CA
Principal Engineer FPGA Design for Intevac at Santa Clara, CA
Technical Support Engineer for EDA Careers at Freemont, CA
Development Engineer-WEB SKILLS +++ for EDA Careers at North Valley, CA
Upcoming Events
IoT Summit 2017 at Great America ballroom, Santa Clara Convention Center Santa Clara CA - Mar 16 - 17, 2017
SNUG Silicon Valley 2017 at Santa Clara Convention Center Santa Clara CA - Mar 22 - 23, 2017
CDNLive Silicon Valley 2017 at Santa Clara Convention Center Santa Clara CA - Apr 11 - 12, 2017
10th Anniversary of Cyber-Physical Systems Week at Pittsburgh, PA, USA PA - Apr 18 - 21, 2017



Internet Business Systems © 2017 Internet Business Systems, Inc.
595 Millich Dr., Suite 216, Campbell, CA 95008
+1 (408)-337-6870 — Contact Us, or visit our other sites:
AECCafe - Architectural Design and Engineering TechJobsCafe - Technical Jobs and Resumes GISCafe - Geographical Information Services  MCADCafe - Mechanical Design and Engineering ShareCG - Share Computer Graphic (CG) Animation, 3D Art and 3D Models
  Privacy Policy